If you’re interested in my scoring system, I’ve written down an explanation here:
1=Stuff that makes me wanna punch a hole in my monitor and makes me feel disgust.
Example: Re:Zero, Psycho Pass 2, Evangelion 3.0
2-4=Anything I’ve dropped. Is either boring or clearly doesn’t appeal to me. If I finish a show in this range, it's because it's part of a larger franchise, or because it's a seasonal show I've already watched a lot of.
Example: Release the Spyce, ReRideD: Tokigoe no Derrida, Kino no Tabi 2004
5=It’s good... but I’ve either seen it done better and it’s mostly just kinda meh. I have no interest in watching more than thirteen episodes. Also what I rate most tie-in OVA's and specials which are basically just "more show".
Example: Comic Girls, Tsurezure Children, Oreimo
6=I mean it's good, but there's a lot of wasted potential. Most 6/10's for me are shows with interesting ideas or subject matters, but which aren't done extremely well.
Example: Yuuki Yuuna wa Yusha de Aru, HaNaYaMaTa, Classroom of the Elite
7=Some solid stuff, though either I don't like it enough, or it just didn't go on for long enough. If I like it a lot, I might even watch another season or an OVA or two.
Example: So Ra No Wo To, Kiznaiver, Usagi Drop
8=Really solid. This is some damn good stuff, and I’ll definitely watch more seasons of this, but it always feels like there’s something missing or holding it back.
JoJo, Iron Blooded Orphans, Mugen no Ryvius
9=It’s a ten but not quite. Has the same qualities as a ten, but it doesn’t have enough of an impact on me to deserve a ten. Still amazing.
Example: Mahou Shojo Lyrical Nanoha A's, Otaku no Video, Psycho Pass
10=Absolutely amazing. This is the cream of the crop, the best of the best. I feel extremely emotionally invested in these characters, the show has great production, and it’s affected my life in a great way.
Example: Love Live School Idol Project, Berserk (1997) and Haibane Renmei